Short answer: To choose a dog trainer, look for someone who uses mainly or only reward-based methods (treats, toys and play), explains what they're teaching and why, and lets you watch a class first. Avoid anyone who uses physical force, intimidation, or choke, pinch or shock collars. Anyone can call themselves a trainer, so it's worth asking questions before you book.

What training methods should I look for?

The American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior (AVSAB), in its position statement on choosing a trainer, recommends trainers who use primarily or only reward-based training, and advises avoiding trainers who use physical force or rely on choke, pinch or shock collars. AVSAB warns that punishment carries risks, including increased fear and aggression. AVSAB's 2021 position statement on humane dog training goes further: it recommends reward-based methods for all dog training and says aversive methods should not be used. See also do I need to be the alpha with my dog?

What does a good dog trainer do?

According to AVSAB, a good instructor explains what behavior is being trained and why, and demonstrates it. In a class, there should be time to practice and get individual help, with small groups or assistants. A good trainer adapts to your dog, keeps learning, and is respectful of both of you.

How do I choose a dog trainer, step by step?

  1. Ask about methods. "What do you use to reward dogs, and what happens if my dog gets it wrong?"
  2. Ask about tools. "Which equipment do you use?" Listen for flat collars, harnesses, treats and toys.
  3. Ask about fear and reactivity. "How do you handle a scared or reactive dog?"
  4. Ask to watch a class. Look at the dogs: loose and engaged, or tucked tails and avoidance? Are people encouraged or scolded?
  5. Check class size. Small groups, or assistants, so you get individual help.
  6. Ask when a vet should be involved. A good trainer knows when a behavior might have a medical cause.
  7. Trust your gut. If anything feels harsh or rushed, it's fine to walk away.

What are the red flags?

Alpha rolling, pushing a dog into position, hitting, choke or pinch collar corrections, shock collars, and anyone who makes you feel bad about how quickly your dog is learning.

What if my dog has a serious behavior problem?

If your dog is aggressive, has bitten, or shows serious fear, ask your vet for a referral to a veterinary behaviorist or a trainer with specific experience in those problems. For reactive dogs, see how to run a first reactive-dog session.

Whoever you train with, your own skills matter too. The Handler guide focuses on the handler side of reward-based training, and the first chapter is free to read.

This article is general education, not veterinary advice. If your dog seems unwell, is in pain, or something changed suddenly, call your vet. If it could be an emergency, don't wait.

Quick check

Does one of these sound like yours?

Choose what fits. Nothing is saved or submitted.

Sources
Sources & care notes

Frequently asked questions

What training methods should I look for in a dog trainer?

Mainly or only reward-based work with treats, toys and play. Avoid anyone who uses physical force or intimidation.

What does a good dog trainer do?

Explains what behavior is being trained and why, demonstrates it, and leaves time to practice and get individual help.

What are the red flags when choosing a dog trainer?

Alpha rolling, pushing a dog into position, hitting, choke or pinch collar corrections, and anyone who shames you about your dog's pace.

What should I do before booking a trainer?

Watch a class and ask your questions. Anyone can call themselves a trainer, so checking is worth it.

When do I need more than a trainer?

If your dog is aggressive, has bitten or shows serious fear, ask your vet for a referral to a veterinary behaviorist or an experienced specialist.

Explore this topic

Sit, stay, lie down: basic commands step by step